Reflections on the Border Patrol

| | Comments (8)

When I was in college, 3,000 miles from where I am today, I was really stunned and distraught to read that many Border Patrol agents were Mexican-American. Though I knew very little about border dynamics at the time, I was struck by the lack of ethnic compassion and recognition of shared immigration stories. Deciding and then undeciding to do thesis research on the topic, it's ironic that by the force of fate, I ended up living and working on the border 3 years later and once again thinking about this tension.

What I initially found puzzling now makes a lot more sense. Although the explicit aim of the BP is to intercept illegal immigration, my conversations with BP agents have led me to believe that they are not consciously nativist in their aspirations. Rather I've found that they're focused on their personal goals for the job, "securing America" and "securing their jobs", their versions of doing good and doing well.

Yesterday I spoke with an aspiring Border Patrol of Mexican descent.  He told me that as a kid in Nogales, Arizona he was really confused about who "illegal aliens" actually were.  He would say, "I'm not an alien", in a childhood recognition that the term was being applied to Mexicans like him, but that he wasn't an extraterrestrial.  Now, he is aware that if he would get into the BP he would be involved in preventing "illegal aliens", Mexicans, not little green men, from entering the country.  When I asked him about his feelings on the matter he responded very genuinely that he would be working against "my people" in some ways, but that he would not be in it for that, but rather for security purposes.  Like many border residents in the US, he's concerned that drug violence may spill over to this side.

A few months ago, I had the chance to talk to another BP, half-Mexican, while checking out at Walmart. During that time, I still saw BP agents as the manifestation of their agency and anti-immigrant policy so I maybe interrogated him too hostilely. I walked away from the conversation angry and indignant, after he had said matter-of-factly that many illegal immigrants were coming to the US to commit crimes, and that the Border Patrol prevents tons of drugs from making it to the US streets (yeah, but the interceptions wouldn't be necessary if the US controlled demand in the first place!).  As time passed though, I became less angry. I've realized that this guy, like the aspiring agent, is motivated by the desire to do what he sees as good, a service to his country.

I am definitely not saying that all causes are equal, or because someone feels good about what they're doing that it's a good cause. Nor do I pardon these guys'  involvement in the BP.  I think that cognitive dissonance has clouded many BPs' judgment in acting correctly and ethically, and actually taking into account that yes, in fact working for the Border Patrol is a betrayal of la gente mexicana. (With reason, many Mexicans call the Mexican-American BP agents pochos, roughly translated as Mexican American traitors.) But I do at least understand where they're coming from and how they see their jobs.

Of course, the wish to do their version of good is only a part of the story, and not the main motivation. The fact of the matter is that the Border Patrol is an attractive job, materially speaking. Salaries start around $40,000 and come with generous benefits and retirement after 20 years. And the BP is always recruiting. Even now, despite the ailing economy, recruitment events are happening around the country. According to my gym buddy, they are currently hiring 11,000 new recruits, and he wants to be one of them (even if he's number 10,999, he says) to have better pay and job stability. And while money is not everything, I can't entirely blame him. For many residents on the US border, not the most thriving part of the country by any means, it is one of the most lucrative options available.

The desire to do well economically, what I believe to be people's main driver to apply to the BP, is the same desire that propels people along the border to get involved in another very unsavory activity, the drug cartels, which like the BP, are said to offer great pay, cars, houses and even insurance to their henchmen. The comparison I think is an apt one, as both those involved in the BP and the drug cartels work for their personal and familial well being first, and above eveything else.  It is highly unfair that, because of the way the system is set up, the BP's pursuit of material well-being is predicated on hindering those south of the border from pursuing theirs.

digg | | delish


Horace said:

You really don't understand do you? Border Patrol agents have no difficulties understanding that their first allegiance is to their country, the United States of America, and that they see themselves as citizens first, not like ethnocentric Latinos with split loyalties to Mexico and other countries south of our border. You'll never understand because you fail to accept the concept of the unity of our people as a nation. As a foreigner we can't really expect you to understand. Don't bother applying for citizenship, because you could never be true to the oath that every prospective citizen is required to cite.

Aly Wane said:

Great blog brother. We are not fighting people, we are fighting a system that is inherently de-humanizing. We must start by refusing to dehumanize even those we struggle against. Keep up the good work. Peace.

basya Author Profile Page said:

It's funny that you assume that as a foreigner I am not a citizen and that I don't feel loyalty or allegiance towards the US. In fact, I was naturalized over a decade ago and I love this country. Patriotism though, true patriotism, is not based on a a blind uncritical acceptance of a country's policies, especially discriminatory ones towards our brothers south of the border, but rather a continual desire to make the country a better and more welcoming place.

A rather obvious reason so many Mexican-Americans (even those that are "half-white", whatever that means) go to work for the Border Patrol is that it pays a heck of a lot more than any other job in small border towns. Also, because speaking Spanish is a job requirement, and so many of our nativists have trouble just with their own English language, a border native is naturally at an advantage for these jobs.

Dave Bennion said:

Moving to a smaller city, I interact at Immigration with a smaller pool of guards, clerks, adjudications officers, judges, and ICE attorneys now. As I get to know them better, it's clearer to me that many are just trying to do their jobs, they believe strongly that what they are doing contributes to the public good.

It's still a tragic system based on pernicious assumptions and fraught with ineptitude. And the interpersonal power dynamics at Immigration are at times nauseating. But people are people. I do think that hiring 11,000 border agents is a poor use of the public purse.

Then there's the view expressed in this poem, funnily enough left by one of my anti commenters (who I doubt is a pacifist)--he saw immigrants as the "soldiers" instead of the guards and ICE officers--you know, the ones tasked with enforcing laws on human bodies:

But without him how would Hitler have
condemned him at Dachau
Without him Caesar would have stood alone
He's the one who gives his body
as a weapon to a war
and without him all this killing can't go on

He's the universal soldier and he
really is to blame
His orders come from far away no more
They come from him, and you, and me
and brothers can't you see
this is not the way we put an end to war.

Horace said:

Grabman said: "Also, because speaking Spanish is a job requirement, and so many of our nativists have trouble just with their own English language, a border native is naturally at an advantage for these jobs."

Check out the graduation rate for Latinos in the Los Angeles school system. It's less than 50%. English is supposed to be their first language, yet few of these failures can barely speak fair English, let alone write well. Nativists have no lock on language problems.

I'd rather have Americans be nativists than transnationalists with no loyalty to any particular country. I could at least be assured that the former wouldn't be torn between fighting for the people of Mexico over the interests of the citizens of the United Sates.

Horace said:

"It's funny that you assume that as a foreigner I am not a citizen and that I don't feel loyalty or allegiance towards the US. In fact, I was naturalized over a decade ago and I love this country."

You state this but it is hardly sincere, as you put the welfare of foreigners above that of citizens. I'll bet that you never gave up your Mexican citizenship, either, an indication that you have mixed feelings about devoting yourself entirely to the welfare of the citizens of this nation.

basya Author Profile Page said:

Once again your assumptions are misguided. I am not Mexican, never had a Mexican passport, and am not even of Mexican descent. You are right about one thing though, I do not put citizenship first. My loyalty is to people, period, irrespective of their countries of birth and their citizenship. That's why I take serious issue with our immigration policy, because it is predicated on the principle that some people (Americans) are more entitled to certain opportunities than other people (non-Americans). Since the place of our births are arbitrary, why should we be rewarded for punished for them?

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by basya published on February 8, 2009 5:24 PM.

Support the Uniting American Families Act: Pro-Migrant SanctuarySphere was the previous entry in this blog.

Stop The Circus! Fight for Tolerance, Stop Arpaio! Musical Monday: Special Hip-Hop Edition is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.